Loneliness vs Aloneness: Lessons From a Solitary Mountain Retreat
First time to The Daily Mind? Why not get FREE email updates and see how you like it?

photo credit: D R E A M MERCHANT
“Whosoever is delighted in solitude is either a wild beast or a god.” - Francis Bacon (English Lawyer and Philosopher 1561-1626)
One of the big things that gets you about meditation training is how quickly you have to come to terms with being alone. When you sit there on your cushion and concentrate on the mind you realize how addicted you are to external stimulation - television, radio, iPod, friends, family, etc. Take them away and you feel lonely and agitated.
So how would you go in a 20 year solitary meditation retreat high up in the mountains? Would you get lonely? Here are some lessons I learned from a man who did just that.
The mountain retreat & the difference between loneliness and aloneness
A few years ago when I was in the Indian Himalayas I was attending a talk by a very important Buddhist meditation teacher. The topic of the talk was “Going on a Buddhist Retreat” and he spent the evening talking about how to plan, prepare for and carry out a solitary meditation retreat in the mountains using lessons from his own 20 year retreat. Let me give you a bit of background information:
Solitary retreat in Tibet
Solitary retreat is an ancient Buddhist tradition that was popularized in Tibet by the master known as Padmasambhava. This master would teach villagers, kings, priests and noblemen (and women!) and then send them off to a cave to meditate alone for years and years with nothing but a blanket and the clothes on their back.
These solitary meditators would soon reach an extraordinary level of meditative realization and peace and as the word spread more and more people ventured off to meditate alone in caves. A great community built up where the locals would bring food and water to these yogis and yoginis and as such they could spend years alone without ever having to leave the cave. Needless to say their meditations became very strong!
The practice of solitary retreat became so infused in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition that almost every single Tibetan Buddhist practitioner will spend some days, months or years alone by him or herself in retreat. I myself went to this teacher to learn how to do a solitary retreat and it was during his talk that I learned the difference between loneliness and aloneness.
Isn’t it lonely being alone for 20 years?
At the end of the master’s talk he asked if there were any questions. I had been a dying to do a meditation retreat for a long time but something was holding me back - loneliness. I decided I would ask him if he ever got lonely when he was alone in his cave for 20 years. I was hoping he would say “yes” and then give me some pointers on how to overcome it.
“I have a question sir,” I piped up.
“Mmmm…” he replied with a smile.
“Did you ever get lonely on retreat?”
“No.”
That was it. No. He didn’t. Everyone laughed a little and looked at each other in disbelief as if he had just told us he didn’t need to breathe air. How could someone spend 20 years alone in a cave and not be lonely some of the time? Well I wasn’t buying it. Just as someone else was raising their hand to ask another question I piped up again, “Really? You never got lonely?”
“Nope,” he assured me without an ounce of doubt in his voice.
I paused hoping for something more. Surely he had something else to say on the matter! After what seemed like half and hour he sat back in his chair and took on a more relaxed demeanor and, as if someone had hit the “play” button, he started talking about being alone.
“In all honesty I never once got lonely,” he began. “You westerners have a strange habit of always having to be entertained. It is as if you can’t stand to be in your own company. I wonder why that is?” he asked himself. “If you want to do a retreat you need to learn the difference between aloneness and loneliness. Being alone by yourself doesn’t necessarily mean you are lonely!”
It didn’t hit me at the time but what he was saying was very profound. At the time I was a little annoyed at him. I thought he was lying. But when I went home and started doing a lot more meditation I came to see what he was talking about. I was addicted to stimulation. I struggled to be alone. The Lama was right - it was as if I couldn’t stand to be in my own company!
As the months and years went by I started to become more comfortable being alone. I saw that the cravings for entertainment were just another destructive emotion that I needed to overcome. Slowly, oh so slowly, I saw that there was, in fact, a big difference between loneliness and aloneness.
The importance of spending time alone
Now I am a few years down the track and I actively seek out aloneness. I need it occasionally to recharge my batteries and sought out my head. In the beginning I was scared of being alone. Now I quite enjoy it.
It is important to actively cultivate some alone time. It might be taking an hour away from technology and just sitting by yourself. It might be having a day away from your regular home life and getting back in touch with who you really are. It might be driving to the country and sitting in forest for a few hours.
And I am not talking about the “alone” time where you go off in to another room and play video games or read a book. I am talking about alone time where it is you, your mind and nothing else. Nothing. When you create moments like these you will come to discover things you never knew about yourself. Valuable things.
Loneliness is an extremely uncomfortable emotion if you get stuck in it. But, if you are afraid of being alone and are constantly searching for stimulation and entertainment you will slowly lose track of who you are - and that is much worse than being lonely.
My challenge for you is to find a couple of moments in the next few weeks to be completely alone. Watch the feelings of loneliness come and go. Watch the cravings for stimulation come and go. Watch all the pitiful excuses your mind will create to get you out of that boring situation. Watch them and let them go. Just sit. Just be alone.
My challenge for you is to discover the difference between loneliness and aloneness and all the wonderful things that understanding brings to your being.
Random Posts
|
Stressed? Anxious? Get my 100% FREE eBook on how to beat stress, anxiety and depression forever. Did I mention it is free? Click here. |
|
|
Stumble it! | Subscribe to TDM |
|
Subscribe by Email |



Great post, really enjoyed it!
Thanks a lot JB. Actually, I wrote it at your house tonight. Haha.
I am a bit envious of your experience with the Buddhist master as I long to go such a retreat myself. But as the mother of four children at ages one to twelve it is an unrealistisk ambition at this time of my life…
Thank you for sharing your experience with me. I found this post very inspiring. These issues are close to my heart as you will find if you visit my blog at: http://missattica.blogspot.com
Hi Miss Attica.
Thank you for your comment. I understand it must be really hard with young kids around. I don’t have kids myself but I worked in child care for 5 years and never have I been so exhausted!
My friend JB who wrote the first comment also has four young kids and has a pretty good strategy for finding some retreat time. I’ll see if I can get him to come back and have a chat.
I think I would like to write more about my experiences with Buddhist masters so stick around if you are interested.
Thanks again.
TDM
Hey Miss Attica,
my wife and i also really want to do retreat, and we also have 4 kids (well, nearly.. 3 and number 4 due next feb..).
i actually think it is a really great way to live a very spiritual life - having a family. aside from all the selfless service, training in patience (lol) and all the nice loving kindness.. it forces you to slow down, be patient with your dreams, and it also gives you time to really prepare well for something like retreat.
because i got dobbed in (*thanks* mr minder..) here is our plan.. it is to slowly increase the amount of time we dedicate to meditation practice each day over the years that the kids live at home, as they slowly become more and more independent, we will (theoretically) have more and more time to put into it. (aswell, this gives us time to gradually build up our meditation fitness, making it more realistic that we could actually sit down and do practice full-time, in a retreat setting..) and then, when they all branch out into their own lives, and their own homes, we hope to go into deeper retreat, which is just basically spending all our time focused on meditation practise, with periods of no contact, silence, etc.
Awesome plan! Thanks for sharing.
TDM
Thanks a lot to both of you for taking an interest in my dilemma!
Good advice JB, I will take it under advisement. It is very important to me to be present for my kids in their childhood period. In retrospect it will seem it went by very quickly, or so I’ve heard…
I now spend about half an hour every morning with yoga, breathing exercises and meditation. The gradually increasing this time sounds like a great plan to me! Looking forward to hearing more about your experience with Buddhist masters, TDM! I’ll be back!
Great stuff. Looking forward to receiving more comments from you Miss Attica!
TDM
I did one week solitary retreat. You need to face yorself avery moment. But even in this case thare are to mach distractions
Jeane I would be really interested to hear more about your week retreat. What came up in your mind? Did you develop any strategies for dealing with loneliness?
Thanks for leaving a comment!
TDM
I’ve heard some goody things about this blog. The content has really been useful a great balance of text and pictures.
Thanks a lot for your compliments Matt. Its always nice to get some positive feedback.
TDM
I don’t understand this. I naturally create hours where I only lie down and think. This is natural for me, I’m 15 and as far back as I can remember this is often how I entertain myself.
Is this a problem only extroverts experience?
Perhaps you are right Loi P. Perhaps only extroverts have this problem. However, I don’t consider myself and extrovert and I still had problems with feelings of loneliness. Perhaps it has something to do with how we were brought up? Interesting… thanks for stopping by.
TDM
I don´t have problems with loneliness. My big problem was afraid to be alone in a solitary place. I cannot sleep for one week. Every sound bacame very intensive.
Jeane that is so true! I know that feeling well. When I was alone in India every small sound becomes a bandit or a terrifying ghost!
TDM
I really enjoyed this post. The one’s about personal experience really captivate me more than simple list posts.
Thank you for taking the time.
James
Thanks James. I think I prefer writing them this way too so hopefully there will be some more soon!
Thanks for your message.
TDM
Absolutely fascinating post, thank you for writing it.
Hi Richard. Thanks for the kind words. Thanks for leaving a comment!
TDM
I really like this post. While I can imagine more brief periods of solitary meditation, 20 years seems astounding to me. It also made me think of the concept of “solitary confinement” in prisons and how this is viewed as near torture. I guess for many Buddhist monks and also Yogis, it may be a welcome reprieve.
Most interesting. Thanks for the post.
Hi Beth.
Its funny you should say that. I remember once talking to an old monk about Australian prisons saying things like, “you only get a small cell with two meals a day and no exercise time…” and his face beamed with joy - “sounds great!” he said!
Crazy! Haha.
Thanks for the comment.
TDM
This was perfect timing for me today–I used to be really good about taking time alone, but lately have gotten out of the habit. Thank you for the reminder!
No worries Jessica. Thanks for commenting.
This was a really interesting post to read…I think so often our society teaches us to always be busy with something, and to not dedicate this precious time to ourselves that is so imprtant.
Wow, great post! I told you I like these about Buddhists
Although I don’t think I’d ever take 20 years from my life just for meditating, and not because I’m afraid of loneliness, but because I think I’d leave a lot of other great experiences out of my life. And I’m really not talking here about any addiction to stimulation.
In fact, I like to be alone. But I’ve also found that it’s quite hard to be completely alone. Another interesting thing is I was thinking about it a few days ago, and I realized I can’t even tell when was the time when I was in compete silence. I mean, no sound at all. I don’t even know how is that feels. Weird. Even in nature there are some sounds. So I decided to find a place and the time when I can experience it fully.
Anyway, thanks for the great article, I enjoyed it very much.